Understanding Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: Pros Cons and Key Differences
- Monica Cistrone NP-C
- Jul 8
- 5 min read
Updated: Aug 10
Let’s face it — health insurance isn’t exactly light reading. Once you hit Medicare age, the number of options can feel overwhelming. Do you pick Original Medicare with a Medigap plan? Or go with one of those all-in-one Medicare Advantage plans you see advertised with smiling seniors on park benches?
If you’ve ever found yourself nodding through a benefits presentation and walking away more confused than when you started, you’re not alone.
Here at IWC Primary Care, we’ve helped hundreds of patients sort through the Medicare maze. If you’ll let us, we’d love to walk you through it too — honestly, clearly, and without the fine print headaches. Because while Medicare Advantage can be a great choice, it’s not without its quirks. That’s why we’re calling this blog: Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage — The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly. Trust us, we’ve seen all three.
But here’s the twist: when you’re with a care team that’s on your side — a team like ours — even the “ugly” can be made better.
Understanding Medicare Options
Let’s break it down with a metaphor.
Imagine Original Medicare is like a classic, well-worn toolbox. It’s dependable. It comes with your basic tools — doctor visits and hospital care. If you want more tools (like drug coverage or extra protection from big bills), you can buy add-ons like a Medigap plan and a Part D prescription plan. You pay a bit more, but you have freedom — you can see any doctor who takes Medicare, no referrals needed.
Now, Medicare Advantage is more like a pre-packaged multi-tool. You get the basics plus a bunch of extras in one neat little case. Drug coverage? Included. Dental and vision? Probably. Maybe even a gym membership or rides to your appointments. And the monthly premium? Often low or even zero.
Sounds great, right?
Well… here’s where things get interesting.
The Good
We’ll start on a positive note — because there are plenty of things Medicare Advantage gets right.
When it works well, it works really well. We’ve had patients come in thrilled about the extras. They love that their glasses are covered or that they can get $100 to spend on over-the-counter products each quarter. They like that it’s just one card and one phone number to remember.
For folks who are relatively healthy and want to keep costs down, Medicare Advantage can be a great fit. Plans keep improving every year.
So yes — there’s good. Really good.
The Bad
But not everything that glitters is gold. Sometimes those shiny extras come with strings attached.
We’ve seen the look on a patient’s face when they realize their plan requires referrals for everything. Suddenly, what felt simple now means waiting — waiting for your primary care provider to request a referral, waiting for your plan to approve it, and sometimes, waiting even longer to get a specialist who’s actually in-network.
And if that referral is denied? You’re back at square one.
The other thing that stings? Narrow networks. You may have picked your plan thinking your doctors were covered, only to find out they’re not — or that you have to travel across town to see a provider you’ve never met.
One of our patients — let’s call her Ms. L — had to change cardiologists three times in one year because her plan kept shifting its network. Imagine building trust with a specialist only to start over and over again. That’s not just frustrating. That’s exhausting.
The Controversial
Now here’s the part nobody likes to talk about.
The most controversial part of Medicare Advantage isn’t the plan itself. It’s what happens when a patient falls through the cracks.
We’ve seen people go months without the care they need because no one was helping them navigate the system. We’ve met folks who were sent from one call center to another just trying to get a prescription refilled — or get an answer on why their test wasn’t approved.
Sadly, we’ve talked to patients who were rushed through appointments, barely looked in the eye, and left with more questions than answers.
If you’ve ever felt like just another number, you know what we’re talking about.
How IWC Primary Care Makes It Better
This is where we change the story.
At IWC Primary Care, we don’t just practice medicine — we advocate. We guide. We listen. And we fight for our patients when the system falls short.
Let’s go back to those common complaints — referrals, rushed visits, and red tape — and show you how we do things differently.
Referrals That Actually Go Somewhere
When you need a specialist, we don’t just send off a referral and cross our fingers. Our team follows it all the way through — making sure it’s approved, helping you schedule it, and confirming that it’s the right match for your condition and your comfort.
We’ve had patients say, “I’ve never had a doctor’s office do that before.” That’s what makes us proud.
Providers Who Slow Down and Listen
Dr. Suzanne Afflalo, Nurse Practitioner Danielle Gordon, and Nurse Practitioner Monica Cistrone aren’t just providers. They’re partners in your health.
They take their time. They ask the right questions. And they make sure you’re heard. Your concerns don’t belong on a checklist — they deserve attention and thoughtful care.
We Handle the Hassle So You Don’t Have To
Prior authorizations? Pharmacy delays? Confusing letters from your insurance? Give us a call. Our team is trained to handle it — and to explain it in a way that makes sense.
At IWC, you’re never left to fend for yourself.
So What Should You Choose?
Truthfully? It depends.
Traditional Medicare gives you more freedom. Medicare Advantage often gives you more convenience.
But neither plan can do it all without the right care team in your corner.
That’s where we come in.
We’re Here — and We’re Ready to Help
Whether you’re new to Medicare or just fed up with feeling overlooked, IWC Primary Care is here to help you make the most of your benefits — and your health.
Located in Spring Valley, California
Accepting most Medicare Advantage plans including SCAN, Anthem Blue Cross, Brand New Day, Molina, Central Health, Humana, Aetna, and more
Proud to serve the communities of Spring Valley, Lemon Grove, El Cajon, and beyond
Call us today at (858)-648-0755 or schedule online at www.iwcprimarycare.com/services
Bonus: Tell Us About Your Medicare Experience
Have a story to share? Frustrated with your plan? Take our 2-minute survey — and get a free download of the top 5 questions every Medicare patient should ask their doctor.
Comments